Rockeology: Old Yellow

old yellow guitar

This post, from 2018, is one of our all-time most popular. It really is one of the coolest little nuggets of rock history we’ve encountered, so it seemed a good time to revisit it. We hope you enjoy it as much as we did. 

For musicians who grew up in the last half of the 20th century, the words “48th Street” conjure up vivid memories of the epicenter of NYC’s robust music industry. The Big Apple’s Music Row was a cluster of instrument retailers along West 48th Street between Sixth and Seventh Avenues, which could service the needs of literally every musician on the planet. World-famous legends, touring sidemen, local session cats and working pros, music teachers, garage band amateurs and beginners, and tourists from around the globe; they could all come to 48th Street and find the tools they needed to bring the music in their hearts to life. After weathering cultural and stylistic changes from the big band era to late-‘90s electronica, the shops slowly faded away as brick-and-mortar retail gave way to 21st-century e-commerce. But an entire generation of musicians continues to cherish their memories of Rudy’s, We Buy Guitars, Alex Music, and others as essential elements of this city’s rich cultural history.

One name not only dominated 48th Street but also possessed a unique cultural artifact that signified the energy of the street and the unity of musicians everywhere. Manny’s Music was a leading music retailer and New York institution for over six decades, epitomizing both the glory and the grind of the music biz. Founded by Manny Goldrich (1904-1968) and famous for its Wall of Fame of signed photos, Manny’s was also home to a guitar called “Old Yellow.” Old Yellow was the unofficial “tryout” guitar at Manny’s: all customers, from average Joes to ex-Beatles, were required to play it when testing out amps or effects. Today Old Yellow is owned by the Sam Ash corporation, and carries a tag that reads, in part: “This guitar has seen more action than a Quentin Tarantino movie!”

The guitar is rightfully poised to enter the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, as part of an upcoming Manny’s-themed exhibit. Ian Goldrich, Manny’s grandson, is both humble and proud of his family’s legacy. “I said to the curator of the hall,” explains Ian, “‘I understand why The Who and Jimi Hendrix are in there, but I’m not quite understanding why you’d want to do something about Manny’s.’ To which the curator replied, ‘We’re not just a museum. We’re here to educate people. And the Manny’s story and the music history of New York is really important to how we’ve gotten to where we are and why the Hall of Fame is what it is.’” That story continues to unfold today, as the heirs to Manny’s Music have now joined forces with former 48th Street neighbor and competitor Sam Ash. But let’s not get ahead of ourselves.

The arrival in the 1950s of Elvis Presley and Buddy Holly, along with the musical and sonic innovations of Les Paul, generated a growing interest in the guitar. But it was The Beatles’ legendary TV appearance on The Ed Sullivan Show on Feb. 9, 1964, that proved to be the instrument’s game-changer. Fred Giovanelli, a Sam Ash employee for over three decades, relays a story told to him by Jerry Ash. “Jerry says to me, ‘Back on February 8, 1964, my store was filled with guitars. Electric, acoustic, basses, everything. By February 12 or 13 there wasn’t one guitar in the store to be had! After The Beatles played, the kids ran into the music stores and wiped the shelves clean! It took several months to start restocking the stores with electric guitars.’”

Related: “The Big Guitar Songs, 1955 to 1974”

“You gotta understand,” Fred continues, “rock and roll was not electric guitar-driven at that point; nobody thought of Buddy Holly as a ‘guitar hero,’ you know what I mean? But now you’ve got a unit where everybody’s equal, and everybody’s got 25% of what makes the song the song. Plus you saw these flashy guitars, solos…it was guitar-driven, and the kids went wild.” Ian Goldrich confirms: “The Beatles kicked it up a big-time notch. It made certain companies; I mean, look at Rickenbacker! They really took advantage of that whole thing.The British Invasion was a jump-start to the heart of the New York City music industry. A new breed of rock stars meant a new breed of customers to the music stores, and the centrally-located Manny’s was primed to accommodate this glamorous new clientele. By this time Manny’s son Henry was working at the store, and just as his father made the store a comfortable “hang” for the jazzers of the previous era, so did Henry welcome The Beatles, The Who, Jimi Hendrix, The Byrds, and countless others into Manny’s. “My father just treated them like regular guys,” Ian says. “He didn’t fawn all over them. He also kept people away when these guys came in, and the guys who worked in the store were never allowed to ask for autographs. And because these stars came in so often the people who worked there were sorta like, ‘Oh that’s kinda cool.’ It’s not like today where it’s on everybody’s social media, tons of pictures and things like that.”

“Someone like Pete Townshend would walk in,” Ian continues, “and Henry would say “Hey Pete! Whaddaya doin’? C’mere, I gotta show you this guitar!” But it wouldn’t be like “Great to see you,’ you know, wouldn’t fawn over him. The old store at 120 West 48th Street had a room upstairs where the guitars were, and he would bring them in that back area of upstairs. It was the same sort of thing when we moved to 156 West 48th. There was a little back area where it was cordoned off, you couldn’t even really see it. And that’s where these guys would go and hang. And they would hang! It would be amazing how many stars would be in the store at any given time.” It wasn’t long before young Ian began to realize that there was something special about the family business. “My brother Judd is two years younger. John Entwistle went to my brother’s bar mitzvah; that’s 13, so I must have known something at 15, you know (laughs)?”

Henry routinely purchased used instruments for resale, and on this day a person (or persons, details are sketchy) brought in a full set of instruments repainted with new, bright colors. Among them was an unremarkable Danelectro guitar that had been painted bright yellow. “It wasn’t a factory color,” Ian says. “In fact now that the guitar has aged, you can see it probably came from the factory as black. It had this little lipstick pickup in it, all stock parts, just the color was different. So it was an off-the-street buy; it didn’t come from the company.” The other repainted instruments were eventually sold, but “the yellow guitar” hung around.

By this time Henry was well-known for his strict policy of forbidding customers to try out new guitars unless they were serious about buying them. NYC guitarist Jack Morer, a Manny’s employee in the mid-80s, remembers his own shopping trips there years earlier: “As a kid, you’d come into the city, and you’d go to Manny’s and say ‘Hey can I play that guitar?’ And someone would always be asking you ‘Are you buying today?’ And they were always really impatient.” Ian concurs: “Listen, 48th Street was not an easy place to buy an instrument. It was intimidating, and it was New York at its finest and worst depending on how you consider it, you know? If you walked into Carnegie Deli, those waiters were not all warm and fuzzy. And that’s kind of how 48th Street was: it was ‘Show us your money, kid!’ It didn’t start on 48th Street but we were certainly a part of it.” Henry’s “show us your money” approach was fair enough; no shopkeeper wants his wares damaged pre-sale. But where did that leave customers looking to test out new amplifiers or effects pedals, who actually needed a guitar to play?

Related: “5 Questions With Master Guitarist Jorma Kaukonen”

“My father realized Old Yellow was a good-playing guitar,” Ian says. “He paid nothing for it basically, and he wouldn’t sell it. So when somebody wanted to try out an effects pedal or an amplifier he wouldn’t let you pull down a new Strat out of the showcase; he said ‘Here, this is the tryout guitar.’” From that point on, it didn’t matter if you were Joe Blow from the Bronx or Joe Walsh from The Eagles: if you were in the market for a new amp or effects unit, you played Old Yellow. The guitar passed through countless famous (and not-so-famous) hands over the ensuing decades. “Everybody who played it said it played really well,” says Ian. “My father tells the story of George Harrison, Paul McCartney, Bob Dylan and John Sebastian sitting in the back of the 156 building, so it’s gotta be in the mid-70s or something like that, and they’re all passing this guitar around when George offered my father $200 to buy it. And my father turned him down!”

Eventually, however, “Old Yellow” met an abrupt end of sorts. “It fell off a guitar stand and the headstock broke off,” Ian says. “That was the end of that.” Despite being damaged beyond repair, the guitar remained in a glass display through the ‘80s and ‘90s as a totem of years past. But as the ‘90s wore on, the tide began to turn for Manny’s. Because of shifting economic factors better explained elsewhere, Manny’s officially closed its doors in 2009.

As for Old Yellow, the guitar currently lives at the flagship Sam Ash store on 34th Street in NYC. But Ian Goldrich hopes that it will soon take its rightful place in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. “The Hall actually paid for the removal of the facade sign,” Ian says. “And then there was a piece of marble out on the front in the sidewalk, and they paid to have that removed as well. They spent a good amount of money and they’re restoring it right now to set up a Manny’s exhibit. So I’m hoping that’s where it ends up. It was as much a part of the history of Manny’s as the building.”

– John Montagna

Photo Credit: Image of Old Yellow by Max Ash courtesy of Sam Ash Music Corp.

Other Posts You Might Like

John Montagna is a bass guitarist, singer, songwriter (but not a “singer-songwriter”) and Brooklyn Native. He has toured the world and elsewhere with Alan Parsons, Todd Rundgren, The Turtles (featuring Flo & Eddie) and many other legendary hit makers, and he created the theme music for the top-rated comedy podcast “WTF With Marc Maron.” John prefers to view his all-consuming obsession with The Beatles as an asset, rather than a liability.

35 comments on “Rockeology: Old Yellow

  1. Tim Glover

    I was in Manny’s probably around the late 80s just before I married my wife. Had to take her to the skating rink there that’s 30 Rock but I wanted to make a stop on Music Row. Got to go in to Manny’s for about an hour or so and one of the first things I saw was some of the pictures on the wall as you go up the steps one of Jimi Hendrix. So amazing to be part of History it’s sad though that the history is over. Farewell Manny’s you will be missed you helped many of us become the musicians that we are today thank you and God bless you.

  2. AH yes, Old Yellow. When I first started playing back in 1967, Manny’s and”We Buy” were always a stop for me. The lure if hoping to see someone famous was too great. And I was rewarded. I remember seeing Hendrix in the old store, Paul Simon and Leslie West too. So when I finally had the bucks in the spring of 1972, I made my way to Manny’s and bought a used Sunn Solaris. But of course before buying, I had to try it out using old yellow. I always treasured the thought that all of the guitar greats, that I looked up to and were influenced by played that that thang. I only hope there’s still a little of my sweaty DNA is still there.

  3. Jim Pappas

    I bought my first guitar, a Guild Starfire III, at Manny’s (at 120 W. 48th) in 1961. I still have the instrument, and it still plays beautifully. During the mid-70’s I spent way too much time in the various shops on 48th. By that time they had moved to 156. I never remember being asked if I was going to buy today, in my memory (at least) you could play any guitar. And you might be playing alongside a top musician. Sam Ash was right next door, and was probably my most-frequented hangout. Across the street at We Buy Guitars I bought a Fender in the mid-70’s. Some years later I went to Manny’s to buy a recording deck, and was told that I had to go to the Brill Building to buy it. Imagine buying musical merchandise from Manny’s in the Brill Building. Almost like being in church. Recorded a demo around the corner at Nola Studios. Great times, great memories.

    • Lovely recollections, Jim. Many musicians of that time likely have similar “wandering 48th Street” stories. It was indeed like being a kid in a candy store…

  4. Cheryl Richards

    Looks like the old yellow guitar needs to be thrown out!

  5. Ayne Ruderman

    My name is ayne Manny was my gpa n mu best friend. I started working in the store when i was 12 . i have great memories n honored to be remembered fondly by others

  6. I purchased my first guitar back in 1964 at Mannys, it was an Epiphone. Biggest memory – saw Ringo/s drum kit with the Beatles logo on it – and was able to take a photo with it. Left NYC in 1967, then back in 2014, for nostalgia, wanted to visit Mannys but alas only the storefront and worn out sign remained. A great treasure in the Rock Hall, indeed.

  7. larry decarmine

    I grew up on that street……………brought much happiness and my future there……

  8. David Bowen

    Every time I went to NYC in the 90s on business, I always made time to stop at Manny’s. My favorite Manny’s story – I walked in one random day, and there was Gene Simmons, standing at the top of the stairs at the entrance, with two beautiful models, one on each arm. Gene is a very tall guy – so standing at the top of the stairs, he looked like a giant. He sticks his hand out, as I walk up the steps, and – in offering to shake hands – says, “Hi, I’m Gene Simmons – and you’re not!” And then lets out a big laugh, and goes back to his business of tending to his lady friends. No cell phone cameras back then, so no selfies – just Gene and his two very well-endowed friends. I love(d) Manny’s …

  9. Hey what ever happened to Buddy Rich’s drums? They used to be up on the wall in Manny’s after he passed away.

  10. I bought my 74 SG at Alex Music after the salesman at Manny’s wouldn’t give me the time of day. That notwithstanding I loved going to Manny’s and wish they were still around. Today’s musicians miss out on just being able to see a part of history from a musician’s perspective it was a great place. I did spend my fare share of $$ there along with the other places along 48th St

  11. I bought a 76 strat at mannys. I love Hendrix and Richie Blackmore and I wanted to get a White Strat and I know that Hendrix used to shop there so I went right to mannys And bought one it cost me 360 With a case I still have it that was my first guitar I bought i used to love going 48th St. and see all the guitar shops there used to love to go we buy guitar’s That was a store that’s sold old used instruments It was a great place to go to back in the 70s and 80s I miss that place you pass by now and it’s nothing there just stores very depressing place when you remember the Good old days when they were guitar shops it’s not the same everything changes but I still have my memories

  12. Salespeople with attitudes, you can’t try the guitars, gee I wonder why they’re no longer in business! I went to Manny’s often when I lived in the city and usually felt worse coming out than I did going in.

  13. Jeremy Finch

    Thanks for the article, Mr. Montagna! I’m a big fan of your YouTube videos, especially the Beatles Remasters videos. I hope you’ll post one about the 50th Anniversary White Album box set.

    • Hey Jeremy, I’m just seeing this comment now (2 years later)! Many thanx for the kind words, believe it or not I don’t have the White Album box yet but the Abbey Road box is awesome.

  14. Douglas Leftwich

    It’s too bad the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame is such a huge joke to all of us rock music fans. They have proven time after time they haven’t a clue about the Rock music genre. With inductees such as Joan Baez, Janet Jackson, and a host of rappers, hip-hop, and dance artists in their fold it is no wonder people question their integrity. They lost the respect of millions of rock fans decades ago. Every year when they announce the inductees there is a huge firestorm of protest. It’s very sad

    • George Price

      Of course, Joan Baez is in…folk predated Rock, but not by much. And with Janet, she’s proven she can outRock the best…including her brother, Michael.

  15. I bought my first decent guitar, a Guild D-40, at Manny’s back in the ’70s. Still have it, albeit it has a little wear.

  16. Kenton Adler

    LOVED Manny’s. I lived in Denver, but visited NYC and bought two Telecasters from them in the mid 80s. A pink paisley reissue, and the Rosewood “George Harrison” reissue. Just walking in the door of that place was like stepping into a shrine.

  17. John Campbell

    2009 was a bad year. For Christmas 1989 my father asked me to make a Christmas list, but with no CDs on it. It was all I’d been asking for for birthdays and Christmas for a few years. So, I put a couple of small items I could use, then added, as a joke, “A Rickenbacker 4001 bass like in the Rush poster over my bed at home.” I was on college. I came down the stairs Christmas morning and saw a large rectangular wrapped object. I knew what it had to be. A blue 1978 Rick 4001. $895, from Manny’s. My father never thought I liked it because, for one of the rare times in my life, I was speechless.

    2009. In March, I lost my father to complication from cancer treatments. In May I got sick and missed a lot of work. I had no insurance or benefits and worked commission, so I was out a lot of money. I had one item of value and sold the bass to Norman’s Rare Guitars in Los Angeles for $900. The Sunset Strip was selling a 1978 blue 4001 for $3200. I had no time for e-bay. It was the only time I was glad my father had died as he wouldn’t see me sell this gift. And apparently Manny’s went away that year as well. I was only in Manny’s once in the late 1980s. I don’t remember much. I can’t believe it’s been 10 years since all that happened.

  18. Brad Misciagna

    I’ve worked in music stores, (to fund my addiction to guitars and amps), since the late 70’s. I only worked at Manny’s for two and a half years. (89-92) But I started going there in the early 80’s. I know it’s only my opinion, but I believe the Goldrich family to be of the finest character, and as much of a gift to music history as any artist. And I’m proud to have worked there, and thankful of the lessons learned.

    As far as the abruptness of the employees I can only say this. It was midtown Manhattan in the 80’s and 90’s. And you had to sell a hell of a lot of instruments to make rent. And I did demo an amp with that guitar. Liked the guitar.
    The amp…not so much.

  19. That Guitar SPOKE TO ME – it wants fixed !!! It’s pissed off! and _IT_wants to be Played by all AGAIN! ( It hates being NAILED TO A WALL and feels CRUCIFIED – WOOD was a LIVING thing- it has a SPIRIT- after all those hands put their energies into that WOOD – it has POWER and its alive as much as you and I — its begging to be repaired and strung up and in the hands of 1000’s again! GET-ER -DONE and visit WWW>UN_CRUCIFY_OLD_YELLOW>COM and sign the petition!

  20. Comments were almost as good as the article!! Fantastic piece of rock writing, well done to you, John, and all at CS!!

  21. wade shaddy

    I’ve built and repaired lots of guitars. This is an easy fix at home with glue and clamps.

  22. Ira Nagel curly.

    I play at manny sons bar mitzvah at the homowack
    Back in the day.
    And I was a Henry groupie.

  23. This poor Dano can be repaired, of course. But what’s the point? They will never let anyone play it anymore anyway. And as a historical artifact that sits behind glass, its condition doesn’t really matter. Kind of ironic that something once so inexpensive and accessible is now neither.

    I have been repairing, collecting, researching, buying, selling and writing about guitars for almost 40 years now. I knew every music store in NYC and had dealings with most of them. I have warm and fuzzy memories of quite a few that are sadly no more. But Manny’s and most others on Music Row, I don’t miss at all. They were the ones I avoided after an initial visit or two back in the 1980s – precisely because of that pretentious, holier-than-thou, “show me the money, kid” attitude. When I was just starting out, Manny’s wouldn’t give me the time of day. By the time I was promoting international music festivals and working with all kinds of famous musicians, I didn’t need them.

    This relic is a cool piece of history and is certainly worthy of being preserved. But it’s emblematic of that self-referential elitism that damaged the spirit of rock ‘n’ roll.

  24. Hi John, Good article. The first time I was in Manny’s was around 1963, in the old store. I disagree with the depiction of the “holier than thou” characteristic at Manny’s. What you didn’t get was condescension. I have been a full-time professional guitarist all my life, but I never looked like one, and what Manny’s people did not do was make me feel inferior to anyone else. Almost all the other experiences with music stores all around the country would be the salesperson looking me up and down and then talking down to me. One thing Manny’s did for everyone was the across-the-board 40% discount off list price for anything in the store. Sam Ash, (Hi Ian), which started in Brooklyn and had a big place on Long Island where people went, would charge list price or close to it for strings, etc. But when they moved onto 48th Street, they had to compete with Manny’s, so you’d get the discount.

  25. Thom Aye

    I played Old Yellow when I was shopping for an amp at Manny’s in the ’70s. Does anybody remember a salesman who had a goatee, smoked a pipe, and played jazz guitar? I think he may have been Latino. He plugged it in for me and played a few hot licks before handing it over.

Leave a Reply (and please be kind!)