California Dreamers: How Outsiders Defined L.A.

There’s something magical (and perhaps a bit cheeky) about outsiders telling us who we are. They see the mythology where locals just see Monday morning traffic. Perhaps that’s why the quintessential soundtrack of Los Angeles—that sun-drenched, canyon-echoing, freeway-cruising sound—came from musicians who weren’t California natives at all, but pilgrims seeking their own golden dream.

In 1976, a band of musical nomads from Michigan, Texas, Colorado, and Illinois gathered in a Hollywood studio to conjure perhaps the most iconic California song ever recorded. Don Henley, with his Texas drawl intact, crooned about a place that “could be heaven or could be hell,” creating in “Hotel California” not just a song but a state of mind. The Eagles, those quintessential California rockers, were essentially tourists who never left, capturing the dark underbelly of paradise with harmonies as smooth as the Pacific Coast Highway on a Sunday morning.

Walter Becker and Donald Fagen—two jazz-obsessed cynics from Queens—had no business defining the sophisticated sound of upper-crust Los Angeles. Yet Steely Dan’s “Babylon Sisters” paints a picture so vivid of Santa Ana winds and West Coast decadence that you can practically smell the eucalyptus and swimming pool chlorine. Their outsider status gave them the perfect vantage point to document L.A.’s beautiful grotesquerie with forensic precision and sardonic wit.

If anyone embodied the California transplant experience, it was Canadian folk singer Joni Mitchell. Having traded Saskatchewan snowdrifts for Laurel Canyon’s eucalyptus groves, Mitchell wrote “California” as a love letter from abroad, capturing that unique homesickness for a place that wasn’t even her original home. When she sings about coming home to California, she’s articulating the feeling millions have had: that California isn’t just a place but a state of belonging you choose.

The cheeky irony of Englishmen Led Zeppelin penning “Going to California” speaks volumes about the state’s gravitational pull on the global imagination. Robert Plant, a man whose childhood landmarks were industrial Midlands factories, somehow perfectly captured the pilgrim’s journey to the promised land of “the queen of angels and saints.” The acoustic tenderness of the song echoes the reverence these British blues-rockers felt for this mythical landscape an ocean away from their rainy homeland.

Perhaps the most fascinating case is Jim Morrison. The self-proclaimed “Lizard King” grew up as a military brat, primarily in Virginia and Florida, yet he became the brooding poet laureate of Tinsel Town with “L.A. Woman.” Morrison’s outsider eye turned the city into a character—at once seductress and adversary. His Washington D.C. accent transformed into something distinctly Californian when he drawled about driving through your suburbs, creating a psychogeography of Los Angeles that locals recognized even if they’d never articulated it themselves.

Then there’s Tom Petty, that Florida boy with the distinctive nasal twang, crafting in “Free Fallin’” what amounts to a three-minute California travelogue. From the Valley to Ventura Boulevard, Petty—who once described himself as “a Southern boy who’d seen the pictures and heard the records”—mapped Los Angeles with the precision of someone who had fallen deeply in love with his adopted home. As he later admitted, “I was so alive there. I was drunk on it all.”

What these musical immigrants understood was that California isn’t just geography—it’s aspiration. They didn’t merely adopt the California sound; they invented it, refracting the sunlight through their outsider prisms. Their songs became more authentically “California” than (almost) anything a native could create, precisely because they could see both the reality and the myth simultaneously. (Shout out to Cali folks Randy Newman for “I Love L.A.” and the Mamas and the Papas for “California Dreaming.”)

In the end, these transplants gave the Golden State the greatest gift possible: they told Californians who they were. And California, ever the gracious host, simply nodded and said, “Welcome home.”

-Staci L. Wilson

Photo: Pexels.com