Possibly because the public at large doesn’t pay much attention to songwriters, and probably because it doesn’t have Jann Wenner’s public relations machine behind it, the Songwriters Hall of Fame lives a quiet existence, given little fanfare. Most years, if you hear about its new inductees, it’s a 20-second blurb on radio news or perhaps a headline in your social media feed. It’s too bad because the Songwriters Hall is at least as full of head-scratchers as its younger cousin, the Rock Hall. A tremendously interesting piece could be written about the shockingly high number of completely out-of-left-field inductees (I strongly encourage you to check out the full list) housed at the Songwriters Hall, but our mission this time around is to explore the people who aren’t in and try to figure out why. Be warned: many of these exclusions utterly avoid any kind of logic or sense, so we may just have to throw in the towel for some [amazon template=right aligned image&asin=B078TQJRRV]of them. Certainly, that’s true for perhaps the Hall’s most conspicuous absence…
1. Neil Young
This is a fact: David Crosby, Graham Nash and Stephen Stills are all members in good standing of the Songwriters Hall of Fame — and Neil Young is not. Read that again. It’s true. The entire catalogue of great songs from those writers, both in their work together, as members of other bands and in their various solo stints, wouldn’t fill Young’s Decade compilation, released more than 40 years ago, while Young has, needless to say, filled at least two Decade-length retrospectives in the ensuing years. Maybe there actually is a cost of induction and Neil just doesn’t want to deal? Your guess is as bad as mine. Which leads us to…
2. Paul Westerberg
Fill in the blank: “Paul Westerberg wrote _______ and on that basis alone deserves to be inducted into the Songwriters Hall of Fame.” You may say “Answering Machine.” Perhaps “Here Comes a Regular” or “Fuck School” or “Can’t Hardly Wait” or “Unsatisfied” or… And there you have it. Westerberg wrote all of those breathtakingly perfect songs, and probably another few dozen on the same level or at worst a small step down. So, if any one song provides justification for its creator’s immortality, what does it say when the writer has scores of those songs? It says the writer deserves to be in the Songwriters Hall of Fame and this is one more instance of an anti-Replacements bias in the mainstream media. Or something like that.
3. Chrissie Hynde
As regards their Rock Hall worthiness, there is no band I go back and forth on more than the Pretenders. A hard look at their resume reveals one brilliant album, two very good albums and a whole lot of “what-ifs.” But as soon as you think that, you can’t help but wonder, “Well, damn, but you can’t keep Chrissie Hynde out of the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame.” This is the cage match that plays in my head as I fall asleep at night. It’s a little easier with the Songwriters HOF. Even after the Pretenders (as a concept) collapsed with the release of 1986’s Get Close, Chrissie continued to put out workmanlike and occasionally very good albums. Many of them had spotty production and uninspired arrangements hampering solid lyrical and musical efforts. (Consider the difference between “Sense of Purpose” from the murk of Packed and the acoustic tickle on Isle of View). And, let’s don’t forget: “You’re gonna make some plastic surgeon a rich man.” ‘Nuff said.
So far as I can tell, there’s no prohibition on songwriting “teams” being inducted. All four members of Queen (yes, I know: not technically a “team,” but you know what I mean) are in, as are all of the Brothers Gibb. So how the most influential and important American post-punk band is MIA is at least as weird as anything the band ever accomplished. Pffft. Incredible underground or quasi-underground acts from the mid-‘80s get overlooked in lots of ways, but R.E.M. became a platinum juggernaut, so it can’t be mere ignorance. Who knows, maybe it’s as simple as assuming that their exclusion has something to do with not having as many hits as Songwriter Hall member Paul Anka or as much of an identity as Toby Keith (both members in good standing.). Or maybe nobody’s in a mood to let Michael Stipe in front of a microphone.
5. The Ramones
Pinheads and glue sniffers and lobotomies, oh my! Come on. Seriously. Just put them all in on the basis of almost all of their work being jointly credited and be done with it. FFS!
PS. Chrissie Hynde’s memoir is as bad-ass as she is. And a look back at R.E.M.’s classic, “Out of Time” album.
Photo of Neil Young by Hulton Archive/Getty Images
Thanks for this, Jeffrey, which I only just noticed. Agree with your suggestions.
From my own research, other painful omissions are folks like Gene Clark, Brooker & Reid, Alex Chilton, Mitch Easter, St Etienne, Bob Mould, Pete Ham, Stephen Fellows, Gram Parsons, Dan Penn, Steve Kilbey, Elliott Smith, and Nils Lofgren.
The rankest omissions would have to be Gene Clark and Gram Parsons.
Lucinda Williams, John Hiatt…
Rose Marie McCoy is not in the SHoF either. Though her early top 10 hits were for R&B artists Big Maybelle, Big Joe Turner, Nappy Brown Ruth Brown, Earl King – artists not played on many white DJs, She also had hits for Elvis Presley, Nat King Cole, Maxine Brown, Ike & Tina Turner, Jerry Butler. She has nearly 850 songs in BMI alone, many for tops artists of the 1950s, ’60s, and ”’0s. And right into the 21st Century she was getting her songs recorded, just for lesser known artists. Her songs have been on Broadway, in movies, and on television. Newer artists are still overing her songs. The Songwriters Hall of Fame seems to have many artists who have written far, far less songs. Then there’s Charlie Singleton. He has 2 songs listed in BMI’s top songs of the 20th Century. It’s estimated he wrote over 1000 songs.
Not in the SHoF.
Yes, it’s crazy that Neil Young is not in the Songwriters Hall Of Fame. He should have been inducted not long after Bob Dylan and Paul Simon. However, it’s good to see that Crosby, Stills & Nash get some recognition for their songwriting, as they usually don’t appear on ‘greatest songwriters’ lists (even though David Crosby’s biggest ‘hit’ is Eight Miles High, which he co-wrote with Roger McGuinn and Gene Clark). Besides the omission of Neil Young, it’s also strange that Warren Zevon, Tom Waits, Townes Van Zandt, Guy Clark, Steve Earle, John Hiatt, Tim Hardin, Judee Sill and, indeed, Gram Parsons are left out. I guess they simply didn’t write enough songs that became hits.
Chip Douglas and Todd Rundgren .
Im not sure if ” hits ” are a prerequisite , but Michael Penn would be my choice right behind Neil Young .