There are people known as “Dylanologists” who can quote you chapter and verse on pretty much every song Bob Dylan has ever committed to tape in his more than half-century of recording. For those people, none of these songs will be much of a mystery. Yet there are also casual Dylan fans who may only know the evergreen albums or the surprise hit singles. To get a complete picture of rock’s most masterly songwriter and most mercurial performer, you need to also know the best of the leftovers, album tracks, and recorded ephemera as much as you need to know the songs that made him a legend. Here are ten of the best.
1. “Boots of Spanish Leather” (1964)
Dylan’s earliest period is known for his protest songs — insightful and fearless. Yet he was also writing complex, tortured songs of lost love that demonstrated he had the heart to match the brains. This wistful track begins as a two-sided conversation from a woman about to make a long journey and the guy she’s leaving behind. On repeated listens, it becomes clear that the final verses belong to the man alone, requesting the titular footwear as one last memento of a shattered love affair.
2. “She’s Your Lover Now” (1966)
Lost in the hullabaloo over Dylan Goes Electric in the mid-‘60s was the fact that he recorded three of the finest albums in rock history in a two-year span, all while touring the world. And still, he found the time to record tracks that didn’t make those albums, such as this wry dissection of a love triangle. The narrator hands off his former lover to a new suitor, and the title seems to be both an admission of defeat and, considering her wild ways, a warning. The best version is the one found on the original Bootleg Series, featuring members of The Band and left tantalizingly unfinished.
3. “I Threw It All Away” (1969)
Even as his most ardent admirers scratched their heads at Dylan’s honeyed voice and country bumpkin lyrics on Nashville Skyline, the rest of the world loved it, particularly the Top 10 hit “Lay Lady Lay.” Listening to it now, the album is largely a light-hearted lark, but “I Threw It All Away” is the real stuff. Taking a cue from his idol Hank Williams, Dylan boils it down to simple expressions of longing and regret in the service of an aching melody. Succinct and stunning.
4. “Sign on the Window” (1971)
Billed as a comeback album after the willfully screwy Self Portrait, the studio LP New Morning is actually middle-of-the-road Dylan, the music a bit too reserved and the words somewhat unfocused. This track stands out though, in part due to Dylan’s unique feel for rhythm on the piano. It also features lyrics where each verse seems to belong to a different song, and yet they somehow all cohere to tell a story of domesticity’s charms winning out over peripatetic pleasure.
5. “Black Diamond Bay” (1976)
Dylan wrote much of Desire with Jacques Levy, who brought some theatrical structure to Bob’s wending narratives. Their collaboration resulted in a couple of epics sourced from figures in the news, but this wholly fictional tale tops them all. Intertwining stories of doomed characters on an island about to be swallowed up by a volcano, the narrator knows all about these poor fools, until the final verse reveals that he seemed to create them from his feverish imagination after seeing a Walter Cronkite news report.
6. “Senor (Tales of Yankee Power)” (1978)
Dylan has acted in westerns and wrote a few songs that seem like they could be translated into a Hollywood oater with no problem (like “Rambling, Gambling Willie” or “Lily, Rosemary and the Jack of Hearts.”) But this song off Street Legal is more of a metaphysical western, with a narrator and an unspeaking companion (who may or may not be a figment of his imagination) trapped in a metaphorical corner and deciding whether or not they should go down fighting. We never learn the outcome, which only makes it more compelling.
7. “Foot of Pride” (1983)
Infidels is the great what-might-have-been album of Dylan’s career. The officially released version finds him transitioning, perhaps a bit tentatively, back to secular material after his born-again albums. But he left some mammoth tracks on the cutting-room floor, including the masterpiece “Blind Willie McTell” and this lesser-known rocker, in which he surveys the state of the world with some of the righteous bile of the Christian albums manifesting itself in tongue-twistingly nimble wordplay.
8. “Dark Eyes” (1985)
Dylan’s ‘80s output was savaged by critics, sometimes rightfully. Empire Burlesque deserves another listen though. The songs are strong, even if the production is a little dated. And this delicate closing track brings Bob back to his roots of acoustic guitar and harmonica, singing a song that seems to be a quasi-autobiographical account of a man who is bewildered by the modern world and removed even from his adoring fans.
9. “Red River Shore” (1997)
It’s hard to find fault with Time Out of Mind, the album that kicked off Dylan’s late-period run of excellence that continues unabated to this day. But it should have found room for this track that was recorded during the sessions. Even a submarine couldn’t burrow to the depths of the heartbreak that the narrator here endures, as he finds himself always on the lookout for a former love that nobody else can seem to remember even existing.
10. “This Dream of You” (2008)
Perhaps it’s coincidence or perhaps it’s telling, but the finest song on Together Through Life is this, the one track on the album where Dylan took the songwriting reins all by himself without help from Grateful Dead lyricist Robert Hunter. In any case, there is a slinky rhythmic feel to this song that is reminiscent of some of the great Drifters classics of the early ‘60s. Meanwhile the lyrics spin a lonely tale of a man who lives his whole life in service of a dream that may never be realized.
PS. Dylan was always controversial, as evidenced by the Trouble No More installment in the Dylan Bootleg recordings. And of course, there was that strange bio pic I’m Not There about him…
Photo: Bob Dylan by William Lovelace/Express, courtesy Getty Images
A good list! Delighted to see This Dream of You on it.
Black Diamond Bay is a gem., with it’s low-key humor observing the ironies of life in the futility of watching disaster faraway.
Dark Eyes is especially moving as a duet with Patti Smith, stage director Jacques Levy wrote the lyrics for Black Diamond Bay and every song on the Desire album except One More Cup of Coffee and Sara, and Girl from the Red River Shore in my opinion should have closed the Time Out of Mind album instead of the 17 minute song HIghlands which is seldom returned to for repeated listens.
ho ho ho, when I play the album (a few times every year) all the songs are in there, including that gem Highlands, with the little story that plays on the Boston docks.
How many times have you heard DIRGE ? And how many of those times have you thought of it ‘reading between the lines’ ?
heard ’em all. that all. you got?
A few observations on these songs from a longtime listener: Problem with “Dark Eyes” is that Dylan is in not particularly good voice on this one; he pretty croaks out the words. “Red River Shoe” could have been a classic but I think Lanois’ production gets in the way here. A different arrangement, one without the accordian, would have been a step in the right direction. As for “Black Diamond Bay,” I have to admit I never cared for the sound of this album. Scarlet Rivera’s violin gets in the way of a lot of songs and sometimes the playing sounds a little of to me ‘ “Oh Sister” for example. The harmonica and violin don’t mix too well on that one. “She’s Your Lover Now” is just fantastic. Whoever stopped playing on the last verse, causing the song to fall apart and to which Dylan is obviously annoyed by the way he says “what,” deserves a good tongue lashing – especially in light of the fact we never got a finished full-band version of this song; at least not one that has ever been released.
I would certainly add “Can You Please Crawl Out Your Window”,
an under-rated GEM!!
Maybe Someday!!…. but this list is good!
Seven Days could have made this list
Thoroughly Dylanologist-pedantic, but Together Through Life/This Dream of You was not released until 2009, not 2008. Don’t flame me!
Great list. This might be bending the rules, but on my list of overlooked favorites is Dylan’s cover of “Can’t Help Fallin’ in Love With You” (from the “odds’n’sods” DYLAN album). I do have to differ with the “Christian bile” comment. I kept hearing and reading that attribution to Dylan’s “Christian period,” but I have to squint to find “bile” on those records. A couple high profile critics hated those records and screamed “bile” and “self-righteousness” etc. and that got repeated enough times for people to parrot it (like a Chairman Mao-ism). In honesty to myself, I hear the opposite of “bile” on those records. Meanwhile, thanks for your work.
Agreed on Dylan’s “Christian period”, while only a handful of songs from that period rank among my favorites, they strike me as a sincere and sympathetic attempt to share his convictions. The live recordings showcased in the 2017 Bootleg Series release make this point especially well.
I have recently become entranced with Brownsville Girl. “People don’t do what they believe in, people do what’s most convenient then they repent” – not sure a better line has been sung. Its 11 minutes of wandering, storytelling, time jumps. All that makes Dylan – Dylan.