Jim Croce: Triumph, Tragedy and Memorable Music

jim croce

When 30-year-old Jim Croce perished in an airplane crash in 1973 (along with co-guitarist Maury Muehleisen and five others), he was just peaking as a folk-rock superstar. Another unbearably poignant detail? He was ready to quit the madness of the road and settle down with his beloved wife Ingrid and toddler son, “A.J.” Croce thought he had played his last public performance in a smallish venue in Natchitoches, Louisiana – a gig he’d booked a year prior for $750, before he became a big name, one that he intended to honor nonetheless.

Related: “Being Jim Croce’s Son: Heartache and Heritage”

Croce had an expressive face overtaken by enormous liquid eyes that held reserves of gentle humor, wisdom, and ineffable sadness. His was the face of a working-class man who had toiled for years in greasy dives playing the music he loved. He took side jobs to support his family – gritty gigs he used for the needed cash and, more importantly, as inspiration for the colorful characters he evoked in his songs. His music hovers somewhere in the folk/soft rock/roots genres, but he’s best known for his soulful melodies and clever lyrics. He was a musical raconteur telling stories of marginalized folks, allowing us to see them through an empathetic lens.

Embrace these Jim Croce tracks again. Dive in and enjoy their bluesy magic.

Operator (That’s Not the Way it Feels) (1972)

A song of aching sweetness about a broken heart and the slow crawl towards acceptance, from the 1972 album You Don’t Mess Around With Jim. The narrator is trying to reach out to an ex-girlfriend who left him for his best friend. He converses with a telephone operator, asking that she connect the call so he can let them know that he too has moved on with his life. This proves impossible when his tear-blurred vision prevents him from giving the correct number. His kindness towards the anonymous operator befits a man who did not deserve his cruel romantic fate. This melodic tear-jerker contains quaint elements: the use of a telephone operator, the discussed dime for the call, the scrawled digits in a matchbook. But the human situation remains fresh and relatable. Croce took his inspiration for this tune (which peaked at #17 on the Billboard charts) from his days in the service, seeing fellow soldiers queueing up at the communal phone to verify the “Dear John” letters they received.

Related: “We Can Make It If We Try: Bill Withers’ Top 10 Songs”

Workin’ at the Car Wash Blues (1974)

A funky addition to the 1974 LP I Got a Name, this track peaked on the charts at #32 and remains a favorite. It also features some maestro-level guitar work. Originally saddled with the lengthy title “I Got Them Steadily Depressin’ Low-Down, Mind-Messin’ Workin’ at the Car Wash Blues,” it’s the tale of a guy who, recently sprung from jail, thinks he’s ready to rule the world and become a cigar-chomping, sexually harassing CEO. Life has different plans for him, and the poor bastard dons his rubber suit and works in a car wash, dolefully walking home in his “soggy old shoes” as he bemoans the injustice of it all. Croce infuses this anti-hero with an oddly endearing quality; it’s a cool song about a lovable loser.

I Got a Name (1973)

Croce was known for writing his own quirky songs, but this life-affirming track is an exception; Norman Gimbel and Charles Fox created it, and Croce gave it his own unique spin. It was released one day after his fatal plane crash, cementing Croce’s legacy. Inside the gorgeous melody is a tale of a man who has been through tough times but has emerged proud, grateful and ready to move forward. With lyrics such as “Like the fool I am and I’ll always be/I’ve got a dream, I’ve got a dream/They can change their minds but they can’t change me”, “I Got A Name” eloquently celebrates the human spirit. It was used to stirring effect in movies including The Last American Hero, The Ice Storm, and Django Unchained.

You Don’t Mess Around With Jim (1972)

A bouncy earworm from the 1972 album of the same name, “You Don’t Mess Around With Jim” is a stellar entry in the pantheon of Croce’s colorful badasses. With quiet glee, he tells us the fate of one such doomed felon. The lyrics are classic:

“You don’t tug on Superman’s cape/ You don’t spit into the wind/ You don’t pull the mask off the old Lone Ranger/ and you don’t mess around with Jim.”

Turns out (spoiler alert!) that the hulking menace gets his comeuppance from the beleaguered “Slim,” but not before we’re shimmying our way through the rest of one of Croce’s most enduring hits.

Bad, Bad Leroy Brown (1973)

Possibly Jim Croce’s best-known and most-beloved song, it hit #1 on the Billboard charts for a week and ranked as the #2 song of 1973. It was his glorious parting gift, sheer boogie-woogie perfection. Another track that pays heed to a brute who meets a deserved retribution at the hands of a wronged man, this jazzy confection sounds as wonderful today as it did in ‘73. Croce’s lyrical descriptions of Chicago bully Leroy Brown as a “treetop lover,” “badder than old King Kong” and, most memorably, “meaner than a junkyard dog” has mugged the guy in perpetuity. Croce was singing about karmic revenge, but he was also sketching out the type of man rarely acknowledged as a muse. And Croce did it with his trademark menschy wink. A masterpiece.

-Ellen Fagan

Public domain image of Jim Croce

Other Posts You Might Like

Ellen Fagan is a forever New Yorker, long-time Greenwich Village resident and vintage Duke University graduate with hippie-esque leanings. The best description of Ellen was given to her by a sardonic lawyer during the voir dire of one of her myriad Jury Duty stints: "...housewife, mom, voracious reader, freelance writer, copy editor, jewelry designer and frequent cyber-sleuth."

11 comments on “Jim Croce: Triumph, Tragedy and Memorable Music

  1. Carmine Bassano

    . . . sheer musical heaven. Thank You!

  2. John Smistad

    What a genius, both as a musician and a chronicler of the human condition. Was so sad as a kid when I heard he’d died. Jim’s indelible spirit lives forever in his songs. Great selection of his tunes, Ellen, to which I would add “One Less Set of Footsteps” and “Roller Derby Queen” as other personal faves. 🙂

    • Ellen Fagan

      Many thanks, John! Your favorites are stellar. I wish I’d made the list longer. 🙂

      • Gina Crawford

        I arrived late to this article but enjoyed it thoroughly nonetheless; thank you. Creating a partial list of Croce’s memorable songs would be quite difficult. Each of his songs touch me somehow: whether with joy and wry amusement; thoughtfulness and reflection; melancholy; or regret for what could have been. That his songs continue to spark the same emotions in me reflect what a gift he was – to me then and now, and to the world at large.

  3. Great article! Jim Croce get me through Junior high. I was very upset when he died. He was one of the good guys.

  4. John Smistad

    I was in Jr High, as well. Tough news for a kid…of any age.

  5. Marc bieler

    Great article! Nice to see this underrated artist get some credit.

  6. Bob Burr

    A wonderfully insightful article, Ellen! I was a freshman in college, with much of life ahead of me, when I heard of the crash that killed him. It was quite a shock, as I was very fond of his music, and remain so to this day.

    Often, with “Time in a Bottle” or “Operator” playing in my head, I wonder about how many more wonderful tunes Croce could have given us to enjoy. The old saying seems so true in his case, as the good so often do seem to die young.

    Thanks for your eloquent tribute to a truly good man and talented artist,


  7. Good list!
    Operator is a masterpiece of creative guitar work and “I’m gonna be strong” bravery in the face of finally admitting it’s over.
    Workin’ At The Carwash Blues is just an indication of the directions that Jim was exploring as he matured artistically. The secret weapon on the track is the swamp/funk drum track from a young Steve Gadd, who was just becoming the go-to studio cat.
    I was devastated to wake up to the news of his death on my alarm clock radio that morning. I often wonder what he would be doing musically today, had he survived. We can only guess. R.I.P. Jim.

  8. Jack moore

    Photographs and Memories

Leave a Reply (and please be kind!)

Love the Beatles? Get this eBook FREE when you subscribe.

It turns out there's a lot to say. Just say "yes" to get yours.