You Told Us, We Dug Deep: 3 Underrated Guitarists

lindsey buckingham

A little while back, CultureSonar asked its Facebook hive mind to name the “most underrated guitarist.” Normally, poking a hive will only get you stung; people love their own opinions, especially about their “favorite” this or “most” that. But the CS hive mind is luckily more enlightened and well-informed than most, so the responses were fairly astute. The majority of guitarists named were either solo artists in their own right, or members of self-contained bands: in other words, as my Breaking It Down with Jeff and John podcast partner Jeff Ganz would say, fully-formed musicians who happen to play the guitar. This not only stimulates a conversation about how music and musicians are perceived, but it also allows writers like myself to dive in and do some “research” in the form of full-attention listening to some tremendous music! Ultimately, three names rose to the top of the heap: musicians who not only cultivated their own distinct voices on the guitar, but did so within unique circumstances of their own creation that allowed them to flourish without mundane comparisons to anyone else. Dig in and enjoy!

Related: “John Lennon: Guitarist”

Glen Campbell (1936-2017) 

It’s impossible to sum up the achievements of this legendary musician in a single paragraph. His tenure as a session guitarist with the famous LA-based “Wrecking Crew” studio collective would have secured his place in music history alone. But Campbell’s transition from sideman to solo artist is unprecedented: sixty (!) solo albums (his final, “farewell” album Adios was released only two months before his death), ten Grammy Awards, and twenty-nine top 10 hits (including nine #1’s) spanning nearly five decades. Though it’s easy to debate which parts and solos Campbell “actually” played with the Wrecking Crew, his massive solo catalog is marked by precision guitar playing that always serves the song. (For a start, that’s him playing the dramatic low-register Fender Bass VI lines on 1968’s “Wichita Lineman,” and 1969’s “Galveston.”) But Campbell was also a familiar face on American television: he hosted his own “Glen Campbell Goodtime Hour” from 1968 to 1972 and appeared as a frequent guest on variety shows like “Hee Haw” and “The Johnny Cash Show,” and a cursory YouTube search of “glen campbell guitar” reveals a treasure trove of stellar fretwork from a generation of such performances. There’s a phenomenal clip from a TNN-TV special where Campbell wows an audience of fellow legendary musicians with an acoustic rendition of his 1968 hit “Gentle On My Mind;” right before the solo Campbell says “I’ll play one…” and Willie Nelson looks up at attention, knowing that he’s about to get a guitar lesson! What follows is blazing, innate musicianship that leaves the gathered luminaries to look on in stunned disbelief. A true American master.

Lindsey Buckingham 

Most guitarists would have been intimidated to fill a chair previously held by Peter Green. But when Lindsey Buckingham joined Fleetwood Mac there was no comparing him to any predecessor: his unique musicianship and rich, powerful songwriting radically updated the sound of the legendary British blues band for a new era. His production chops and multi-layered guitar parts are a master class in rock studio craft, and his fiery leads helped turn songs like “Go Your Own Way,” “You Make Loving Fun” and “The Chain” into monster hits that jump out of radio speakers to this day. But Buckingham could also scorch the earth as a soloist, holding his own in a mid-70s rock scene riddled with “guitar heroes” (Peter Frampton, Rick Derringer, Ted Nugent, etc). Onstage, Buckingham often resurrected the jam-fueled, bluesy spirit of classic Mac by turning their radio hits into springboards for lengthy and dramatic improvisation. Initially favoring Gibson Les Pauls before settling on his trademark mahogany-bodied Rick Turner “Model 1” guitar, Buckingham utilized a plectrum-free, finger style technique to attack his instrument with bloodthirsty abandon.

Related: “Why Does (Almost) No One Record Squeeze’s Songs?”

Glenn Tillbrook

At the height of Squeeze’s success, Tillbrook and his songwriting partner Chris Difford were regarded as “the new Lennon and McCartney” for their sophisticated, post-punk take on English pop songwriting craft. But Tillbrook’s perfectly constructed guitar breaks in the “middle eight” always elevated Squeeze’s mini-masterpieces to new heights. His solos on classics like “Another Nail In My Heart,” “Is That Love” and “Black Coffee In Bed” have become essential elements to the songs themselves: brilliant, active counter-melodies navigating the chord changes with laser precision, punctuated by a lightning-fast vibrato and always landing rock-solid in the rhythmic pocket. And it seems like Tillbrook is still up to his old tricks: check out his dirty, spacious riffs on the soul-flavored “The Ones” from 2017’s The Knowledge. 

-John Montagna

Photo via Getty Images

PS. We first ran this post back in 2019, but the conversation was lively — and worth revisiting!

Other Posts You Might Like

33 comments on “You Told Us, We Dug Deep: 3 Underrated Guitarists

  1. It still amazes me how Terry Kath continues to be overlooked.

    • Yeppppppppppp. I think it’s mostly because Peter Cetera and his douchefriend manager spoiled Chicago for everyone with their sappy music produced in the 80’s. All of Katy’s hard work and brilliance gets overlooked.

    • elevensbest

      Absolutely! A barn-burner of a guitarist given plenty of room to roam in what casual listers think of as a horn-lead pop band.

  2. Nice to see Glenn Tilbrook receiving the deserved recognition.

    P.s. did you, John Montagna, used to play with Francis Dunnery? How does he rank in underrated guitarist world?

    • Yes I did! FD is in a class by himself as a singer, songwriter AND guitarist. A monster musician, had some magical moments onstage w him and drummer Graham Hawthorne.

  3. Terry Szink

    I´ve always thought that Richard Thompson was one of the best.

  4. How about Michael schenker or Leslie West…or Johnny winter….. or Martin barre……I could go on forever

  5. Mike Whitfield

    Nice to see Tilbrook receiving some well deserved love, but Campbell & Buckingham? C’mon dude, they’re both widely acknowledged guitar masters.

  6. James Haviland

    Snowy White! Check out The Wall Live in Berlin…

  7. Jeremy Shatan

    Phil Keaggy was phenomenal from the start – he made his first album with Glass Harp in 1970. I also think Dave Mason is completely taken for granted, such great melodic stuff and he never overplays.

  8. Always overlooked in these polls is Alex Lifeson of Rush! He may be the greasiest technical guitarist of all time! Yet, Geddie and Neil get all the love!

  9. Doug Nieman

    Lowell George. Little Feat forever.

  10. Kerry Ward

    Billy Duffy of the Cult and Don Felder of the Eagles

  11. All those guys are fantastic can’t argue with any I would definitely put terry kath on the list. Guitarist that Hendrix looked up to. That guy was incredible

  12. Michael Gurley from Dada. Always plays the right part for the song, yet can set it on fire for a blistering solo.

  13. Richard Thompson
    Mick Box
    Martin Barre

  14. Dan Genest

    Excellent, well thought out list. Another Nail In My Heart is my desert island song. Forever amuses me how they never actually say that in the song. My wild card pick Roy Buchanon.

  15. Buck Dharma

  16. Ricky Wilson of the B-52s was a great guitarist with immediately recognizable style.

  17. Well outside my normal genre, but Roy Clark was a monster. Google his solo that he did on The Odd Couple for a weird guest spot on the old sitcom. Apparently he did it in one take on the spot. The man was a monster – and never really got the acknowledgement he deserved for his talent.

    • Yes that is one incredible performance. The sheer speed of his strumming is hard to fathom.

  18. Patrick Hooker

    Greg Edwards from Failure/Autolux and currently on tour with APC

  19. Always thought Glen was is the top 5 of all time. No distortion or effects to hide behind. As technical and tasteful as anyone. Evh could tap but Glenn would have smoked him. Glenn and Roy Clark 2 most underrated guitarists ever!

  20. Harry Steinenty

    Lists of underrated are tough. What is is that makes a guitarist underrated, hell if I know. In my world, I certainly agree that Campbell and Buckingham don’t get anywhere enough love. I could sit and listen to them play guitar for hours.
    Tillbrook, puts some great solos into his songs but it’s much more about the songs than the guitar. I. This category I would add a Elliot Easton from the cars and Dave Edmunds in his many different modes.
    You might consider Roy Clark, Bill Kirtchen, Jorge Jorgensen. They are all incredible players that have a great body of guitar music out there.

  21. Billy Zoom of X is still sadly overlooked.

    • elevensbest

      Much love for Billy (and you for mentioning him). Just saw X live in Portland last month!

Leave a Reply (and please be kind!)